Turn the ship before the numbers do: Why health care regulation (the HPOA) belongs near the top of your thinking for the BC Provincial election on October 24
In our Community Voices series, we highlight real stories and unique viewpoints from outside our clinic walls. Today’s guest post is written by Josephine De Virgilio, a Writer & Communications Professional, who explores why your vote matters in the Provincial Election.
A ship the size of health care does not turn on a dime. By the time the statistics show it has drifted, it is already far off course.
That is what makes this election different from most. The changes in how BC regulates its health professionals will not show up in a wait-time chart or an annual report for some time. You will find them now only in conversations: a psychologist deciding what work to take on, a physician weighing how long to stay, and professionals in many fields asking the same question in different words. Who decides how I am allowed to care for people, and who decides what happens to me if they disagree?
When professions that rarely agree start agreeing
Doctors, psychologists and other health professionals have different training, different regulators and different worries. They rarely organize together. When they start raising the same concern, it is worth asking why.
Nobody picks a fight with the body that holds their licence for fun. For many, speaking publicly is not a comfortable choice. That so many are doing it anyway is information, and it is the best early warning anyone has right now.
The plain version of the law
The Health Professions and Occupations Act (HPOA) has been in force since April 1. It governs how doctors, nurses, psychologists and many others are regulated. In plain terms:
- The Minister of Health appoints every board member of every health regulatory college. Elections to those boards have ended.
- The office that oversees all of them is established “as an office of the government,” and it must follow the Minister’s directions.
- The Minister appoints the person who runs the discipline tribunal.
- A regulator’s assessor can inspect a psychologist’s records, including confidential client information.
None of this is about any one person or party. It is a structure. Who appoints the boards, what powers they hold, and what rights professionals have. Whoever forms government on October 24 will inherit it.
Public interest is not political interest
The law was introduced in the name of the public interest. Protecting the public is a goal every health professional shares. But the public interest and a government’s political interest are not the same thing. Governments are meant to have political interests. That is what elections are for. We believe health regulation is one of the few places where that interest should stand outside the door.
Who holds a regulator to account? The regulator answers to the Minister. The Minister answers to the Legislature. The Legislature answers to you. You are the last link in that chain.
Trust the people who live by a code
Statistics are a rearview mirror. They tell you what already happened. What is happening now, the retiring a little earlier, the narrowing of what people are willing to take on, the quiet reconsidering, will show up in them later, and by then it will be a trend line, not a warning.
Until it does, the best evidence is the people who work in this system. They live by codes that say do no harm, and more than that: heal, help and nurture toward health and wellness. They have no reason to speak up if it does not matter.
Health care belongs on your list
There are many issues in this election, and your priorities are your own. Wait times, emergency care, family doctors, mental health, affordability. All of them depend on professionals who can practise, stay and trust the system around them. Whichever priorities you vote on, we ask that regulation of the people who deliver health care be on the list.
Elections are moments when tides can shift, and tides shift when people pay attention. What happens to health care regulation over the next four years depends on whether enough of us do.
What you can do
- See where candidates stand on repealing and replacing the HPOA: www.hpoa-psychologists.com/election-2026
- Ask your own candidate. A short email is enough.
- Talk to your own health professionals, and to colleagues in other professions.
- Vote. Advance voting runs to October 21, and election day is October 24.
Know the ballot, research the issues, and make sure to vote
Psychologists of BC for Ethical Care and Governance is a non-partisan, independent group, who do not endorse or oppose any party or candidate, and who are not telling anyone how to vote.
Practitioners from Ontario are watching this with interest. Our Act the RHPA was enacted 35 years ago and is updated by way of incremental modernization as needed. Some of us are astounded that the overhaul in BC was so dramatic given the issues could have been addressed with profession specific statutes and amendments without completely dismantling the foundational pillars of traditional professional self-regulation. Thankfully Ontario has preserved this, and has protected elements of democratic peer elections (in fact it is a balanced mix of peer-elected professionals and public appointees). We have also preserved our separate colleges – each answers directly to the Minister of Health without an intermediate government enforcement office dictating daily affairs. One things that makes some psychologists in Ontario shudder is the public disclosure and removal of presumption of privacy during an ongoing investigation. In ON, investigations are strictly confidential until completed and before becoming a part of public record, protecting practitioners from unproven reputational ruin. I hope regulated practitioners are successful in repealing and replacing this law before it sets a dangerous precedent. BC’s mistake will be a lesson for the rest of Canada to pay close attention to.
We must get this Act repealed, revision is not an option. There is no incentive to work in BC, especially doing contentious work like custody and access assessments. Also, physicians will not be enticed to move to BC if they read the HPOA, as they will not like working under threat of massive fines and imprisonment!
Thank you for this article. All of the issues around health “care” are so important. We need legislation that keeps everyone safe–the public and the providers. “Care” can only happen with strong legislation that is fair and reasonable.